5.) Grand Theft Auto V
Yes, this was GTA V's controversial torture/interrogation scene major news outlets couldn't stop talking about. Players can choose between a variety of infamous torture techniques to get information out a person who was already willing to give the information in the first place.
You can pull out his teeth, electrocute him, or break his knee cap with a wrench. To be fair, it was a satire of torture and it's apparent in Trevor's dialogue later on. It could have been done better, but I don't think it's something people should fuss about so much.