• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Gameranx

Gameranx

Video Game News, Lists & Guides

  • News
  • Features
  • Platforms
    • Xbox Series X
    • PS5
    • Nintendo
  • Videos
  • Upcoming Games
  • Guides

Sony Says Microsoft Is Harassing Them, Requests Limits To FTC Subpoena

February 13, 2023 by Ryan Parreno

It turns out Sony and Microsoft have already been getting nasty with each other behind the scenes of this case.

Hold on to your seats as the latest back-and-forth between Sony and Microsoft has gotten quite ugly.

Source: Sony

Earlier, we had reported that Microsoft subpoenaed Sony in relation to the FTC trial for their acquisition of Activision Blizzard King. Today, the FTC released documents from both companies making new demands from each other in regards to the case. This will be a lesson on how such a subpoena would work when companies call each other’s competitors to do it.

As reported by Dualshockers, Sony calls Microsoft’s demands in the subpoena as obvious harassment, and wants them to limit the scope of the subpoena. But what does Sony mean by that?

Microsoft named several people under Sony as ‘custodians’ of specific information that they want presented in court. Sony explains the scope and cost of their requests is unreasonable, and unnecessarily exhaustive for what they want. Sony says the records Microsoft requests goes as far back as 11 years and could cost Sony up to $ 2 million to produce.

But, that isn’t the obvious harassment Sony is referring to. In a redacted detail referred to as “Request 13”, Sony says that:

“Microsoft’s demand for performance reviews for SIE’s (Sony’s) leadership is obvious harassment. Even in employment cases courts require a specific showing of relevance before requiring production of personnel files.

This is not an employment case.

Microsoft speculates these documents may “candidly” discuss the performance of SIE’s gaming business, but SIE will be producing ordinary course documents that directly relate to its gaming business in the files of the Seven Custodians.”

Apparently, Microsoft is going so far to ask for performance reviews for members of Sony’s management, just one of their many requests. Sony now wants the FTC to cut down the scope of the subpoena so that they won’t have to share as many documents and information. It should be noted here Sony has yet to give the FTC and Sony any documents.

Prior to Sony’s request, Microsoft made their own request to the FTC, to deny Sony’s fourth request to delay the subpoena. Microsoft accuses Sony of generally acting in bad faith, refusing to comply with the subpoena, pointing out the three prior requests to delay. The two parties had to negotiate what information Sony would share, and they have generally not been able to agree on final terms.

But Microsoft dropped this bombshell in their request:

“SIE is refusing to produce any documents from Greg McCurdy, who has been deeply involved in SIE’s global campaign against the Microsoft/Activision deal.

SIE claims that Mr. McCurdy is a lawyer and the associated burden of reviewing his documents for privileged material is not justified. To address SIE’s concerns, Microsoft offered to limit the search of Mr. McCurdy’s files to only those documents and communications shared outside of SIE. SIE continues to refuse to collect a single document from Mr. McCurdy.”

Sony also referred to this request on their document, sharing these details:

“Microsoft originally said it wanted Mr. McCurdy’s documents because it believed he communicated with the FTC, worked [redacted] and [redacted].”

So, Microsoft believes Sony’s lawyer Greg McCurdy communicated to the FTC, and said something that could be used as evidence in this case. Microsoft is trying to force Sony to share documentation of what Greg said to prove it. Notably, Sony is openly blocking that request.

Based on the dates indicated in these documents, the two have been at this against each other since the subpoena was served in January.

Share this post:

FacebookTwitterLinkedInPinterest

Recent Videos

GTA 6 - Before You Buy

GTA 6 - Before You Buy

10 HUGE Moments That Shaped GTA 6

10 HUGE Moments That Shaped GTA 6

Bodycam Zombie Game is INSANE

Bodycam Zombie Game is INSANE

20 Worst Video Game Adaptations EVER

20 Worst Video Game Adaptations EVER

GTA 6: 25 Things You NEED TO KNOW

GTA 6: 25 Things You NEED TO KNOW

NEW GTA6 GAMEPLAY,  TWO NEW ASSASSIN'S CREED GAMES LEAKED? & MORE

NEW GTA6 GAMEPLAY, TWO NEW ASSASSIN'S CREED GAMES LEAKED? & MORE

20 NEW Zombie Games That Are Trying Something DIFFERENT

20 NEW Zombie Games That Are Trying Something DIFFERENT

10 MORE Games That AGED LIKE FINE WINE

10 MORE Games That AGED LIKE FINE WINE

20 Game Franchises That DIED For Dumbest Reasons

20 Game Franchises That DIED For Dumbest Reasons

Category: UpdatesTag: Activision Blizzard King, Microsoft, Sony

Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • The Game Awards Just Leaked Manni L. Perez For GTA 6 – By Nominating Her
  • GTA 6’s 2022 Hacker Arion Kurtaj Has Officially Pled Guilty In Court
  • Physical GTA 6 Buyers Are Claiming They Aren’t Getting The Codes In Boxes
  • Hacker Confirms GTA 6 Won’t Be Dumped On PS5’s Latest Firmware
  • GTA 6 Was Almost Banned In Korea – Was It Censored In Japan?

Copyright © 2026 · Gameranx · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Mai Theme