• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Gameranx

Gameranx

Video Game News, Lists & Guides

  • News
  • Features
  • Platforms
    • Xbox Series X
    • PS5
    • Nintendo
  • Videos
  • Upcoming Games
  • Guides
  • News
  • Features
  • Platforms
    • Xbox Series X
    • PS5
    • Nintendo
  • Videos
  • Upcoming Games
  • Guides

id Software’s John Carmack Comments on Game Engine Development

January 14, 2013 by Ian Miles Cheong

John Carmack weighs in on his development of the engines for both Quake 3 and Doom 3.

carmack

John Carmack is well known, and well respected for his work in videogames—particularly in his development of FPS game engines such as those in Doom, Quake and most recently, Rage. His engines have served as strong backbones for games like Half-Life, the Call of Duty series, and other heavy hitters.

Responding to an article on Kotaku about the beauty of Doom 3’s source code, John Carmack added some comments of his own about his thought process while developing the engine and how he thinks the code is cleaner compared to his work on C++, as he considers it “a final evolution of [his] C style, rather than the first iteration of [his] C++ style.”

He explained how he “meandered” into C++ with the newer game, basically experimenting with the coding language. He wrote about how he wished he’d read up more on the language before jumping into it.

In some ways, I still think the Quake 3 code is cleaner, as a final evolution of my C style, rather than the first iteration of my C++ style, but it may be more of a factor of the smaller total line count, or the fact that I haven’t really looked at it in a decade. I do think "good C++" is better than "good C" from a readability standpoint, all other things being equal.

I sort of meandered into C++ with Doom 3 – I was an experienced C programmer with OOP background from NeXT’s Objective-C, so I just started writing C++ without any proper study of usage and idiom. In retrospect, I very much wish I had read Effective C++ and some other material. A couple of the other programmers had prior C++ experience, but they mostly followed the stylistic choices I set.

I mistrusted templates for many years, and still use them with restraint, but I eventually decided I liked strong typing more than I disliked weird code in headers. The debate on STL is still ongoing here at Id, and gets a little spirited. Back when Doom 3 was started, using STL was almost certainly not a good call, but reasonable arguments can be made for it today, even in games.

I am a full const nazi nowadays, and I chide any programmer that doesn’t const every variable and parameter that can be.

The major evolution that is still going on for me is towards a more functional programming style, which involves unlearning a lot of old habits, and backing away from some OOP directions.

Carmack has a much longer post up on the subject at the #AltDevBlogADay blog, which you can read here.

Share this post:

FacebookTwitterLinkedInPinterest

Recent Videos

10 Games That RUINED Single Player Games For Us

10 Games That RUINED Single Player Games For Us

20 LEGENDARY Games Worth Revisiting in 2025

20 LEGENDARY Games Worth Revisiting in 2025

CHEATER FINED $175000, RED DEAD ONLINE RETURNS? & MORE

CHEATER FINED $175000, RED DEAD ONLINE RETURNS? & MORE

What The HELL is GOING on With Xbox?

What The HELL is GOING on With Xbox?

10 LOCKED Areas Developers Didn't Think WE'D UNLOCK

10 LOCKED Areas Developers Didn't Think WE'D UNLOCK

Top 25 NEW Games of 2025 [Second Half]

Top 25 NEW Games of 2025 [Second Half]

10 WEIRD Gaming Stories of June 2025

10 WEIRD Gaming Stories of June 2025

10 1000 IQ Moments in Video Games That Are GENIUS

10 1000 IQ Moments in Video Games That Are GENIUS

25 Best Isometric RPGs That DEFINED A GENERATION

25 Best Isometric RPGs That DEFINED A GENERATION

Category: Updates

Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Pokémon Go: Hisuian Lilligant Raid Day Schedule and Bonuses
  • Death Stranding 2: How To Find Mr. Impossible’s Cargo | Secret Locations
  • Splitgate 2: How to Play Ranked
  • Best New Games of June 2025
  • Roblox The Hatch Egg Collecting Guide

Copyright © 2025 · Gameranx · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Mai Theme