• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Gameranx

Gameranx

Video Game News, Lists & Guides

  • News
  • Features
  • Platforms
    • Xbox Series X
    • PS5
    • Nintendo
  • Videos
  • Upcoming Games
  • Guides

Judge Corley Cited Final Fantasy XVI As A Reason For Her MS Injunction Decision

July 20, 2023 by Ryan Parreno

It wasn’t Starfield or The Elder Scrolls that worried the judge, but Final Fantasy.

Thanks to a newly unredacted version of District Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley’s decision, we now know a key reason why she blocked FTC’s injunction, clearing the way for the MS Activision deal.

Florian Mueller shares the pertinent section, but you can read it yourself in page 9 of the document. As Judge Clorey stated;

“As a game publisher, Sony’s PlayStation Studios, is responsible for blockbuster hits like God of War, The Last of Us, and Spider-Man, the vast majority of which can be played only on PlayStation.

And as a purchaser of third-party games, Sony views exclusive content as crucial to PlayStation’s continued success and to “differentiate [their] platform.”

As a result, Sony offers far more exclusive first- and third- party titles than Xbox. Sony also enjoys “an enormous competitive advantage” because it can draw on the intellectual property of “Sony Music, Sony TV, and Sony’s film library” for its game development.

The number of exclusive games available on PlayStation dwarfs the number available on Xbox, with eight exclusive games on PlayStation for every one on Xbox.

Sony has often paid third-party studios to “skip” Xbox—either entirely or to delay a title’s release on Xbox.

For example, on June 22, 2023, while this trial was happening, Square Enix released Final Fantasy XVI, the latest release in the iconic Final Fantasy franchise, exclusive to PlayStation 5.

Previous versions of Final Fantasy shipped on Xbox, but the reason Final Fantasy XVI is a PlayStation exclusive is because Sony “pa[id] to exclude Xbox.”

ZeniMax, too, was paid by Sony not to ship Deathloop or Ghostwire for Xbox, and one of the reasons Microsoft bought ZeniMax was concern Sony would also arrange for Starfield to go exclusive and skip Xbox.”

We have highlighted the pertinent part in bold, but it was worth sharing the whole passage to understand the full context.

Clearly, Judge Corley did use the little time given to her to study the industry, given what prior knowledge she may already have, and the documents given to her by the FTC and Microsoft. She also demonstrates a clear understanding of the industry, in particular the practices surrounding platform and timed exclusivity.

And so, her clear understanding of the situation with Final Fantasy XVI turned out to be pretty damning of the FTC’s case. The FTC’s intention to expand the reach of their agency, towards blocking large mergers on basis of their scale, turned out to be indefensible in the face of power moves from even more powerful players.

Square Enix probably did not want to even get involved in this, but Sony can only blame themselves for it. They made the deal for Final Fantasy XVI, and probably paid Square Enix enough to make that exclusivity worthwhile.

For us gamers, this exclusivity status may seem commonplace and not unusual. After all, isn’t PlayStation closely associated with Final Fantasy, so it makes sense that the games are sometimes exclusive, right?

But perhaps this industry practice was always up for scrutiny. As you may remember, members of US government have raised questions about PlayStation’s dealings in the industry, precisely because of deals like this. There is a non-zero chance that in the following months or years, the US government will very much be investigating Sony next.

Share this post:

FacebookTwitterLinkedInPinterest

Recent Videos

GTA 6 - Before You Buy

GTA 6 - Before You Buy

10 HUGE Moments That Shaped GTA 6

10 HUGE Moments That Shaped GTA 6

Bodycam Zombie Game is INSANE

Bodycam Zombie Game is INSANE

20 Worst Video Game Adaptations EVER

20 Worst Video Game Adaptations EVER

GTA 6: 25 Things You NEED TO KNOW

GTA 6: 25 Things You NEED TO KNOW

NEW GTA6 GAMEPLAY,  TWO NEW ASSASSIN'S CREED GAMES LEAKED? & MORE

NEW GTA6 GAMEPLAY, TWO NEW ASSASSIN'S CREED GAMES LEAKED? & MORE

20 NEW Zombie Games That Are Trying Something DIFFERENT

20 NEW Zombie Games That Are Trying Something DIFFERENT

10 MORE Games That AGED LIKE FINE WINE

10 MORE Games That AGED LIKE FINE WINE

20 Game Franchises That DIED For Dumbest Reasons

20 Game Franchises That DIED For Dumbest Reasons

Category: UpdatesTag: Bethesda, deathloop, Final Fantasy XVI, Ghostwire: Tokyo, PS5, Sony, Square Enix

Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • The Game Awards Just Leaked Manni L. Perez For GTA 6 – By Nominating Her
  • GTA 6’s 2022 Hacker Arion Kurtaj Has Officially Pled Guilty In Court
  • Physical GTA 6 Buyers Are Claiming They Aren’t Getting The Codes In Boxes
  • Hacker Confirms GTA 6 Won’t Be Dumped On PS5’s Latest Firmware
  • GTA 6 Was Almost Banned In Korea – Was It Censored In Japan?

Copyright © 2026 · Gameranx · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Mai Theme