• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Gameranx

Gameranx

Video Game News, Lists & Guides

  • News
  • Features
  • Platforms
    • Xbox Series X
    • PS5
    • Nintendo
  • Videos
  • Upcoming Games
  • Guides

More EA-Battlefield 3 Review Shenanigans

October 24, 2011 by Mat Growcott

Arthur Gies, who has just reviewed Battlefield 3 for Joystiq, has spoke out about the rules set in place by EA over the reviewing of their latest DICE-made baby

So we realize that a localized branch of EA may have been withholding review copies from jounalists unlikely to give Battlefield 3 a close to perfect score. That's annoying and the localized branch apologized and said that sort of thing hasn't happened before and wouldn't happen again.

Flash forward less than a week and it's happened again.

Arthur Gies' review of Battlefield 3 is largely positive. He highly recommends the multiplayer but disliked the single player and co-op modes. The game recieved a very respectable 4.5, but the review has a backstory that is rather interesting.

Posted to Tumblr, Arthur discusses the backdrop to his writing the review.

"Less ideal has been everything surrounding the review and Battlefield 3’s release. I won’t dwell on the weird goalpost moving that DICE and EA have tacitly encouraged over the last few days by insisting that console reviews can’t be done because of a day one patch that, I guess, would fix anything anyone could possibly find wrong with the game? That’s practically unheard of before a game comes out, and having reviewed… one, two, three, four EA published shooters over the last two years (Bad Company 2, Medal of Honor, Bad Company 2 Vietnam, and Crysis 2), it was especially surprising here. Put more clearly, EA has never done this with any of the games of theirs that I’ve reviewed. Even Bad Company 2, which I believe also had a day one patch, was reviewed on debug hardware with a near-final version of said patch.

"I wonder if I was nicer to the campaign than I should have been. It’s not actively bad, usually, but it’s nowhere near what I would consider good, or even acceptable, really. And co-op stinks. 

"I essentially had to write off two out of three modes in the game. It’s a situation where I have to hope that someone wondering about the game who sees the score will read the review and understand what I tried to say."

EA are definitely playing with the media on this one and given their attitude over the past 12 months when discussing the game, that doesn't surprise me. What is surprising me is the uncaring way in which they're doing it, this is the second time in less than a week that these practises have come out and, other than a half-assed apology, nobody at the company seems at all troubled by the fact that they are, in fact, manipulating review scores.

Every company likes to see their games get good reviews, not just in the game industry. Most of them do it by putting their heart and soul into their product and making sure that it's as good as it can possibly be, not by using their considerable power over the people reviewing.

Share this post:

FacebookTwitterLinkedInPinterest

Recent Videos

GTA 6 - Before You Buy

GTA 6 - Before You Buy

10 HUGE Moments That Shaped GTA 6

10 HUGE Moments That Shaped GTA 6

Bodycam Zombie Game is INSANE

Bodycam Zombie Game is INSANE

20 Worst Video Game Adaptations EVER

20 Worst Video Game Adaptations EVER

GTA 6: 25 Things You NEED TO KNOW

GTA 6: 25 Things You NEED TO KNOW

NEW GTA6 GAMEPLAY,  TWO NEW ASSASSIN'S CREED GAMES LEAKED? & MORE

NEW GTA6 GAMEPLAY, TWO NEW ASSASSIN'S CREED GAMES LEAKED? & MORE

20 NEW Zombie Games That Are Trying Something DIFFERENT

20 NEW Zombie Games That Are Trying Something DIFFERENT

10 MORE Games That AGED LIKE FINE WINE

10 MORE Games That AGED LIKE FINE WINE

20 Game Franchises That DIED For Dumbest Reasons

20 Game Franchises That DIED For Dumbest Reasons

Category: Updates

Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • The Game Awards Just Leaked Manni L. Perez For GTA 6 – By Nominating Her
  • GTA 6’s 2022 Hacker Arion Kurtaj Has Officially Pled Guilty In Court
  • Physical GTA 6 Buyers Are Claiming They Aren’t Getting The Codes In Boxes
  • Hacker Confirms GTA 6 Won’t Be Dumped On PS5’s Latest Firmware
  • GTA 6 Was Almost Banned In Korea – Was It Censored In Japan?

Copyright © 2026 · Gameranx · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Mai Theme