Batman: Arkham Asylum
Similar to how the Metal Gear Solid games would break the fourth wall and mess with your mind, Arkham Asylum throws a bait and literal switch, making you replay the beginning of the game as the Joker. It doesn’t end there either, it doesn’t just mess with the player, it actually messes with the Batman’s mind inside the game as well! BA points to Rocksteady for doing a solid on that one.