• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Gameranx

Gameranx

Video Game News, Lists & Guides

  • News
  • Features
  • Platforms
    • Xbox Series X
    • PS5
    • Nintendo
  • Videos
  • Upcoming Games
  • Guides

Gearbox Jokes About Nerfing Borderlands 4’s Crit Knife – But It’s Not That Bad?

October 24, 2025 by Ryan Parreno

You’ll be surprised how many people in the community are fine with this.

Table of Contents[Hide][Show]
  • What Was The Crit Knife?
  • Gearbox Announces The Big Changes
  • Is It Really That Bad?

Gearbox has finally made the dreaded nerf… but it seems the fans are OK with it?

What Was The Crit Knife?

It’s been a little over a month since Borderlands 4 players found the dreaded Crit Knife. Originally, players went hunting for Knife with a Penetrator Augment.

For this to work, players also had to use Vex, activate her Bloodletter Skill, and pair that with the Specialization called Contamination.

Eventually, players figured out that they could make a similar build if they found a Jakobs knife with Crit Damage.

While fans were happy to get a powerful build almost immediately, that happiness flipped to a situation Gearbox was trying to avoid. Players were getting bored playing, especially after ending the main campaign the first time.

Gearbox Announces The Big Changes

In the patch notes for yesterday’s patch, they announced these changes to Vex:

Incarnate – Vexcalation

  • Bleed from Bloodletter has been updated so it no longer recursively triggers itself, preventing unintended damage loops

They also shared this change under Gear

Reduced critical chance on Jakobs crit knife to 30%

  • Dev Note: It had to happen, you knew it was going to happen!

As if to rub it in, Gearbox made this “RIP Jakobs Crit Knife” video and posted it to Twitter:

https://twitter.com/Borderlands/status/1981439046326100412

Is It Really That Bad?

Fans were quick to see how this worked out in game. Moxsy shared their findings on Twitter:

ATTENTION BORDERLANDS GAMERS!

The new crit knife sets your crit chance to a target at 30%, it DOES NOT ADD 30% Crit Chance. Meaning if you have above 30% crit chance throwing it will hurt your damage.

Chatter mentioned @Lazy_Data figured this out and I just tested to confirm.

Lazy Data also explained it in their own words:

Ok Gearbox are wilding for this one.

Crit Knife is 30% chance to Crit. Full Stop.

If you have crit chance boosts on gear, crit knife will OVERRIDE IT so the enemy is at 30% regardless.

Still very up in the air with testing rn so bare with but… whew

We went looking around for how the community reacted, and it seems to be much better than you would expect. There are people who are negative, but there are also players who are fine, even happy, about it.

EpicNNG said that this change was incredible. When some fans were wondering if he was being sarcastic, he explained what he meant:

It’s 30% crit chance. That is still insane. I would not be saying the same if it were 5%.

While 30 % is not 100 %, in practice getting one critical hit out of 3 is still a really high percentage. Vex remains a very powerful character, and players will just have to put a little more effort to keep dominating.

Share this post:

FacebookTwitterLinkedInPinterest

Recent Videos

20 Forgotten RPGs That Nobody Remembers

20 Forgotten RPGs That Nobody Remembers

20 Games Where You’re Actually NOT HUMAN

20 Games Where You’re Actually NOT HUMAN

10 Open World Games That NEVER REALLY END

10 Open World Games That NEVER REALLY END

SONY CLOSES MAJOR STUDIO, HEAD OF XBOX RETIRES & MORE

SONY CLOSES MAJOR STUDIO, HEAD OF XBOX RETIRES & MORE

20 Best Recent Games That Are NOW DIRT CHEAP

20 Best Recent Games That Are NOW DIRT CHEAP

10 Upcoming Games With INSANE Graphics

10 Upcoming Games With INSANE Graphics

Resident Evil Requiem: 10 BIGGEST CHANGES

Resident Evil Requiem: 10 BIGGEST CHANGES

20 AA Games We CAN'T WAIT To Play

20 AA Games We CAN'T WAIT To Play

50 BEST Sci-Fi Games You SHOULD NOT Miss

50 BEST Sci-Fi Games You SHOULD NOT Miss

Category: UpdatesTag: 2K, Borderlands 4, Gearbox, PC, PS5, Take-Two, Xbox Series X/S

Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Rumor: Microsoft Adding Subs For World Of Warcraft, Minecraft, Fallout, ETC To Game Pass
  • Rumor: GTA V & GTA Online Will Remove Ability To Use Snapmatic For Profile Pics
  • Game Key Reseller Lists GTA 6 Price At Over $ 100 (Is It A Placeholder?)
  • Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories Is Getting A Native PC Port From The Community
  • Ubisoft Has Deployed Their “Teammates” Generative AI Project To Their Developers

Copyright © 2026 · Gameranx · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Mai Theme